I haven’t been the only one that has been hard on
the Pittsburgh Pirates in recent years given how long they have gone without
putting together a winning season, but also because of how little impact talent
they have developed over the last five to 10 years.
Much of that lack of talent had to do with their
approach to scouting and player development, often passing on more talented
players in the draft due to financial implications. I have always contended
that it is one thing to pass on such a player because of such factors, but in
doing so you have to make sure to select the right player in those situations.
In addition, the Pirates haven’t had much luck when it
comes to injuries, losing many to most of their top pitching prospects to
significant arm-related injuries, causing them to miss playing and development
time, or even seeing their once bright potential careers quickly fade away.
Last winter the Pirates had a change in management,
starting with new team President Frank Coonelly and General Manager Neal
Huntingon, both of whom made it clear that they were going to place a greater
emphasis on player development, recognizing that the only way they could turn
the Pirates organization around was to follow the lead of teams such as the
Twins, Brewers and Rays by starting at the bottom and working up. Such an
approach as shown by those teams will take years for the effects to be noticed
at the big-league level, but it quite frankly is the only way for an
organization like the Pirates to get back on track.
As this year’s draft approached, I had still heard
from several scouts and other people familiar with some of the top
draft-eligible prospects that the Pirates were prepared to select a player
other than Pedro Alvarez given his own bonus aspirations. The Pirates did
indeed take Alvarez when it was all said and done, signing him just before the
August 15th signing deadline, for money they previously had been unwilling to
spend, a first big step in the right direction for the organization.
Their generous spending did not stop with Alvarez.
While they were unable to sign their second-round pick, Tanner Scheppers, who
fell in the draft due to injury concerns, they were able to sign a trio of
former Aflac All-Americans for money higher than the recommended slot values:
Sixth round pick Robbie Grossman, 16th-rounder Wes Freeman and 19th-rounder
Quinton Miller. Overall the team signed 32 of their 50 draft picks, and it’s
hard to fault them for not signing Scheppers given the amount of money they
devoted to their entire draft effort.
The talent acquisition for the Pirates didn’t stop
with the draft. Before the trading deadline they dealt three of their more
productive big-league players, Jason Bay, Xavier Nady and Damaso Marte, for two
separate prospect packages.
Xavier Nady and Damaso Marte were dealt first to the
Yankees in exchange for four minor league players. Outfielder Jose Tabata is
one of the more exciting prospects in all of baseball despite being slowed the
past couple of years by a broken hamate bone. Tabata may very well be the
eventual replacement for Nady, as the two share similar profiles as
offensive-minded corner outfielders.
The other three prospects obtained were a trio of
right-handers, Ross Ohlendorf, Dan McCutchen and Jeff Karstens. Karstens was
immediately plugged into the Pirates starting rotation, and has fared well so
far, with the other two being sent to AAA.
The second prospect haul the Pirates received came in
a three-way trade that involved Jason Bay and Manny Ramirez, and the overall
upside of that collective deal is considerably greater than what they received
for Nady and Marte.
Third baseman Andy LaRoche had nothing left to prove
at the AAA level in the Dodgers organization, but with the Dodgers in a
“win-now” mode, they seemed hesitant handing him the everyday job at the
big-league level. The Pirates, playing for the future and not for this season,
can afford to deal with the growing pains of allowing young players to take the
field, and they could have filled a need at third base for years to come, with
a pair of LaRoche brothers now manning the infield corners.
Outfielder Brandon Moss was in a similar situation
with the Red Sox. Like LaRoche, it remains to be seen what his overall ceiling
is, but he’ll definitely be given every opportunity to prove he’s an everyday
big-leaguer.
Two former first-round right-handed pitchers were also
acquired in this deal, Bryan Morris from the Dodgers and Craig Hansen from the
Red Sox. Morris has a ways to go before he starts thinking about becoming a
big-leaguer, but he has an electric arm and plenty of upside.
No player on the field looked the part of a
big-leaguer as much as Donovan Tate did. With a perfectly proportioned,
muscular frame, Tate has a tool package that will have him being discussed as a
potential top three to five overall pick for next year’s draft.
Hansen also has an electric arm, but has been unable
to make a successful transition to the big-leagues, as he was initially drafted
by the Red Sox with the idea that he would become their closer of the future.
Jonathan Papelbon’s development in that same role made Hansen somewhat
expendable, and again, the Pirates can be more patient with his development
hoping that a change of scenery will help him get back on track.
Some have criticized the deals the Pirates made,
giving up three solid, big-leaguers without receiving a legitimate, impact
prospect in return. However, they did acquire eight solid players, and quite
often rolling the dice on unproven commodities has as much to do with throwing
as many as you can into your system to see which ones stick.
And when you couple the prospects acquired in trade
with the players the team drafted and signed this summer, you have a pretty
impressive overall haul of talent. That talent is going to take a few years to
make its mark to get the Pirates back on track, and they still have a long ways
to go, but it’s a pretty good start.
USA Medal
Congratulations are in order for the bronze-winning
Team USA Olympic team. They were able to sneak into the medal round with an
extra-inning win over Japan, lost to national powerhouse favorite Cuba in the
semifinals, and then beat Japan again to secure the bronze.
Korea was one of the biggest surprises of any Olympic
team in any event. They put together an incredible streak that carried them all
of the way to the gold medal game against Cuba, a team no one gave Korea much
of a chance to knock off. But they did just that to claim gold, once again
supporting the idea that the game of baseball is alive and well not only here
in the United States, but across the globe.
The thoughts and opinions listed here do not
necessarily reflect those of Perfect Game USA. Patrick Ebert is affiliated with
both Perfect Game USA and Brewerfan.net, and can be contacted via email at
pebert@brewerfan.net.